"The irrationality of the "appeal to Nature" is illustrated by a simple thought-experiment. Imagine, fancifully, if starvation, disease, parasitism, disembowelling, asphyxiation and being eaten alive were not endemic to the living world - or such miseries have already been abolished and replaced by an earthly paradise. Would anyone propose there is ethical case for introducing them? Even proposing such a thought-experiment can sound faintly ridiculous."
More by David Pearce (philosopher)
See allResonant Thoughts
"British Empire. First trip to India. Glorious. Never would have believed it would all be gone in my lifetime. Not possible, I’d’ve thought. I am the last king-emperor, you know. My brother was, for a …"
"Here is an empire in which is the only relic of the oldest civilization of the world—one which, 2,700 years ago, according to some authorities, had a system of primary education—which had its system o…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"A single life doth well with churchmen; for charity will hardly water the ground, where it must first fill …"
— Francis Bacon"It's this accursed science," I cried. "It's the very Devil. The medieval priests and persecutors were right…"
— H. G. Wells"Virtues are, in the popular estimate, rather the exception than the rule. There is the man and his virtues.…"
— Ralph Waldo Emerson"Enquire: 'Who am I?' and you will find the answer. Look at a tree: from one seed arises a huge tree; from i…"
— Sri Anandamoyi Ma"You are permanent, but this life is not," Mr. Whittier would say. "You don't expect to visit an amusement p…"
— Chuck Palahniuk"It is as a composer that his name will live longest. He was the last of the colourful Russian masters of th…"
— Sergei Rachmaninoff