"Nobody doubts that the Russians committed aggression, that Saddam Hussein committed aggression. We attribute to them rational goals, maybe they wanted to control the energy of the Middle East or something. With regard to ourselves, it's impossible... We just cannot adopt towards ourselves the same sane attitudes that we adopt easily, in fact reflexively, when others commit crimes... And if anyone says it, educated people, liberal intellectuals, are infuriated. Because it suggests that we could do something that's not noble. We can make mistakes, that's easy. You can criticize mistakes. You can criticize low-level crimes, like Abu-Ghraib, you can criticize that. You can criticize My Lai. But not the educated, civilized people, the kind of people we have dinner with, see at concerts, sitting in air-conditioned offices planning mass-murder. So that's beyond criticism. On the other hand, if it's half-crazed G.I.s in the field, uneducated, don't know who's going to shoot at them next, you can blame them, you can say how awful they are. You can criticize Lynndie England, disadvantaged young woman, very different from us. But how about the guys who organized and planned it? No."
React to this quote
More by Noam Chomsky
See allResonant Thoughts
"I remember an old proverb. It says that youth thinks itself wise just as drunk men think themselves sober. Youth is not wise! Youth knows nothing about life! Youth knows nothing about anything except …"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Knowledge isn’t restrained by the limits of Malthus. Information doesn’t need topsoil to grow in, only free…"
— David Brin"My confidence in Spinoza rested on the serene effect he wrought in me, and it only increased when I found m…"
— Baruch Spinoza"It's never enough to say you’re from London, people want to know exactly where you’re from. They see it as …"
— Michael McIntyre"In that Renaissance there was an explosion of unique truthfulness, a love of painting and form.. .Then come…"
— Paul Cézanne"Would you trust the linguistic intuitions of someone who has been studying Latin or Greek for three days?"
— Larry Wall"Man such as we know him, is a machine."
— G. I. Gurdjieff
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Baruch Spinoza on knowledge
- Thomas Carlyle on knowledge
- Friedrich Nietzsche on knowledge
- Immanuel Kant on knowledge
- Aristotle on knowledge
- Arthur Schopenhauer on knowledge
- Michel de Montaigne on knowledge
- Ludwig Wittgenstein on knowledge
- Baruch Spinoza on philosophy
- Baruch Spinoza on mind
- justice & Beauty
- justice & Change