#time
"Why don't you generalize it, and say, can you conceive of any action which any state might take? Sure, you can imagine such things. Let's say you're in Iran right now. It's under attack by the world's superpower, with embargoes... It's surrounded by states either occupied by its superpower enemy, or having nuclear weapons. Little way down the road is the regional superpower, which has hundreds of nuclear weapons, and other WMDs, and is essentially an offshore US military base. And has a bigger and more advanced air force than any NATO power, outside the United States. And in the past year has been supplied by the global superpower with 100 advanced jet bombers, openly advertised as able to fly to Iran and back to bomb it. And also provided with what the Hebrew press calls special weaponry, nobody knows what that means, but if you're an Iranian intelligence analyst you're going to give a worst case analysis, of course. And has actually been publicly provided with smart bombs, and deep penetration weapons... They have a terrific justification for anticipatory self defense, better than any other case I can think of. But would I approve of their bombing Israel, or carrying out terrorist acts in Washington? No, even though they have a pretty strong case, better than anything I can think of here. Just as the Japanese had a much better case than any that I can think of here, but I don't approve of Pearl Harbor. So yeah, we can conceive of cases, and in fact some of them are right in front of our eyes, but none of us approve of them. None of us. So if we don't approve of them in real cases, why discuss hypothetical cases that don't exist? We can do that in some philosophy seminar, but in the real world there're real cases that ought to concern us."
React to this quote
More by Noam Chomsky
See allResonant Thoughts
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Only through apprehending, by means of present-day creations, how art is created, can the creations of othe…"
— Harold Rosenberg"You know, you get these people that are, like, "Here, I was talking to her on Monday... Was it Tuesday? Was…"
— Lee Evans (comedian)"But that's what I'm saying to you... That there are bad people in this world, and sometimes bad people stay…"
— Khaled Hosseini"I was one of a research party of eleven persons that visited the Far East in 1894. During our stay—three an…"
— Baird T. Spalding"A truer image of the world, I think, is obtained by picturing things as entering into the stream of time fr…"
— Bertrand Russell"The conjunction of the day and the night is the most auspicious time for calling on God. The mind remains p…"
— Sarada Devi