"My objections to Marx are of two sorts: one, that he was muddle-headed; and the other, that his thinking was almost entirely inspired by hatred. The doctrine of surplus value, which is supposed to demonstrate the exploitation of wage-earners under capitalism, is arrived at: by surreptitiously accepting Malthus's doctrine of population, which Marx and all his disciples explicitly repudiate; by applying Ricardo's theory of value to wages, but not to the prices of manufactured articles. He is entirely satisfied with the result, not because it is in accordance with the facts or because it is logically coherent, but because it is calculated to rouse fury in wage-earners. Marx's doctrine that all historical events have been motivated by class conflicts is a rash and untrue extension to world history of certain features prominent in England and France a hundred years ago. His belief that there is a cosmic force called Dialectical Materialism which governs human history independently of human volitions, is mere mythology. His theoretical errors, however, would not have mattered so much but for the fact that, like Tertullian and Carlyle, his chief desire was to see his enemies punished, and he cared little what happened to his friends in the process."
React to this quote
More by Bertrand Russell
See allResonant Thoughts
"I am probably the least sensuous of all living beings; being almost exclusively visual and quasi-abstract in imagination, and tending to view and enjoy all things as a passive, detached, and sometimes…"
"He waited for the roll-call to end, reflecting on the likely booty attached to a dead American pilot. Soon enough, one of the Americans would be shot down into Lunghua Camp. Jim tried to decide which …"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Fiction as History: James Jones, From Here to Eternity"
— James Jones"For in the last analysis it is human consciousness which is the subject matter of history."
— Marc Bloch"Our pride and progress could be unqualified if the story might end here. But history reveals that America h…"
— Martin Luther King"Muslim discourse is currently a tissue of myths, conspiracy theories, and exhortations to recapture the glo…"
— Sam Harris"The sound of a jet, an engine warming up, even the clopping of shod hooves on pavement brings on the ancien…"
— John Steinbeck"In history, the arrival of a small man in a big hat is rarely good news."
— Andrew Marr
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Friedrich Nietzsche on history
- Baruch Spinoza on history
- Thomas Carlyle on history
- Immanuel Kant on history
- Friedrich Nietzsche on life
- Friedrich Nietzsche on truth
- Friedrich Nietzsche on philosophy
- Friedrich Nietzsche on time
- Friedrich Nietzsche on knowledge
- Friedrich Nietzsche on justice
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change