"The Machine Age’s commitment to cause and effect was the source of many dilemmas, including the one involving free will. At the turn of the century the American philosopher E.A. Singer, Jr., showed that science had, in effect, been cheating. It was using two different relationships but calling both cause and effect. He pointed out, for example, that acorns do not cause oaks because they are not sufficient, even though they are necessary, for oaks. An acorn thrown into the ocean, or planted in the desert or an Arctic ice cap does not yield an oak. To call the relationship between an acorn and an oak ‘probabilistic’ or ‘non deterministic causality,’ as many scientists did, was cheating because it is not possible to have a probability other than 1.0 associated with a cause; a cause completely determines its effect. Therefore, Singer chose to call this relationship ‘producer-product’ and to differentiate it from cause-effect."
React to this quote
More by Russell L. Ackoff
See allResonant Thoughts
"Look what they have said about the space craft photos which show objects entirely different from any made on Earth—and which have been photographed by many people in different parts of the world! So, …"
"'Tis sufficient to say, according to the proverb, that here is God's plenty. We have our fore-fathers and great-grandames all before us, as they were in Chaucer's days; their general characters are st…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Since the 1990s technology has taken some of the sheen off the Russian trainers and their methods."
— Viswanathan Anand"Most college students, fortunately, are brash enough never to bother asking their elders for advice, which,…"
— Joel Spolsky"Any bit of nonsense can be computerized—astrology, biorhythms, the I Ching—but that doesn’t make the nonsen…"
— John Allen Paulos"You see how increasingly the only way we in the advanced industrial nations, with our bewildering technolog…"
— James Burke (science historian)"The combination of low culture and high technology is one of the most fascinating social features of the vi…"
— Charles Bernstein"We're told that the Arabs loathe us. Really? For liberating the Iraqis? For subsidising the lifestyles of p…"
— Robert Kilroy-Silk
