"Comrade Trotsky completely misinterpreted the main idea of my book, What Is To Be Done? when he spoke about the Party not being a conspiratorial organization. He forgot that in my book I propose a number of various types of organizations, from the most secret and most exclusive to comparatively broad and ‘loose’ organizations. He forgot that the Party must be only the vanguard, the leader of the vast masses of the working class, the whole of which works ‘under the control and direction’ of the Party organizations, but the whole of which does not and should not belong to a ‘party.’ Now let us see what conclusions Comrade Trotsky arrives at in consequence of his fundamental mistake. He had told us here that if rank after rank of workers were arrested, and all the workers were to declare that they did not belong to the Party, our Party would be a strange one indeed! Is it not the other way round? Is it not Comrade Trotsky’s argument that is strange? He regards as something sad that which a revolutionary with any experience at all would only rejoice at. If hundreds and thousands of workers who were arrested for taking part in strikes and demonstrations did not prove to be members of Party organizations, it would only show that we have good organizations, and that we are fulfilling our task of keeping a more or less limited circle of leaders secret and drawing the broadest possible masses into the movement."
React to this quote
More by Leon Trotsky
See allResonant Thoughts
"The easiest way in which one can put unintentional strains on the enemy is to have a force which looks "trigger-happy." The one circumstance under which almost all Soviet experts agree the Russians mi…"
"Science Fiction has long been babbling about cosmic destructions and the ending of either physical or civilized worlds, but it has all been displaced babble. SF has been carrying on about near-future …"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"While our leaders and the Supreme Court keep chanting, ‘All religions are one’; while they keep recalling t…"
— Arun Shourie"Our leaders should stop singing about murdering people"
— Ernst Roets"Lead, follow, or get out of the fucking way."
— Arthur Uther Pendragon"At the vital moment there seems to be a failure of leadership, and also a failure of the general human spir…"
— Jan Smuts"Had Kala lived, Tarzan would have sacrificed all else to remain near her, but now that she was dead, and th…"
— Edgar Rice Burroughs"Your ancestors invaded Macedonia and the rest of Greece and did us great harm, though we had done them no p…"
— Arrian