"compelling case that this system is not only flawed but produces serious and systematic injustice. One major theme pressed in a number of chapters is that the international criminal justice system that has emerged in the age of tribunals and “humanitarian intervention” has replaced a real, if imperfect, system of international justice with one that misuses forms of justice to allow dominant powers to attack lesser countries without legal impediment. No tribunals have been established for Israel’s actions in Palestine or Kagame’s mass killings in the DRC. Numerous authors in Justice Belied stress the remarkable fact of the ICC’s exclusive focus on Africans, with not a single case of charges brought against non-Africans. And within Africa itself the selectivity is notorious – U.S. clients Kagame and Museveni are exempt; U.S. targets Kenyatta, Taylor, and Gadaffi are charged. The system has worked poorly in service to justice, as the authors point out, but U.S. policy has had larger geopolitical and economic aims, and underwriting Kagame’s terror in Rwanda and the DRC and directing the ICC toward selected African targets while ignoring others served those aims. Many of the statutes and much political rhetoric accompanying the new ICJS proclaimed the aim of bringing peace and reconciliation. But this was blatant hypocrisy as the exclusion of aggression as a crime, the selectivity of application, the frequency of applied victor’s justice, and the manifold abuses of the judicial processes have made for war, hatred, and exacerbated conflict. The authors of Justice Belied do a remarkable job of spelling out these sorry conditions and calling for a dismantling of the new ICJS and return to the UN Charter and nation-based attention to dealing with injustice."
React to this quote
More by Edward S. Herman
See allResonant Thoughts
"The first essential of civilization is law. Anarchy is simply the handmaiden and forerunner of tyranny and despotism. Law and order enforced with justice and by strength lie at the foundations of civi…"
"When France fought under kings and for kings it was intrepid and great; today when it fights for the people, for freedom, for the triumph of laws of its making; today, when it only takes out its sword…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"We stand now where two roads diverge. But unlike the roads in Robert Frost's familiar poem, they are not eq…"
— Rachel Carson"Failure in the management of practical affairs seems to be a qualification for success in the management of…"
— Eric Hoffer"Y'all ever seen these commercials for these pills, this medication you take? It's like one pill for one th…"
— Tim Hawkins"Once the church is ready to associate with instituted power it is obliged to associate with all and sundry …"
— Jacques Ellul"When men hire themselves out to shoot other men to order, asking nothing about the justice of their cause, …"
— Herbert Spencer"he magician emerges from bed and we recount our tale. Her response lacks gratitude: stammering furiously, s…"
— Jonathan Stroud
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- David Cay Johnston on justice
- Norman Angell on justice
- Rudiger Dornbusch on justice
- Robin Hahnel on justice
- René Girard on justice
- David Cay Johnston on politics
- David Cay Johnston on time
- David Cay Johnston on life
- David Cay Johnston on knowledge
- David Cay Johnston on art
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change