"The distinction between central and peripheral claims is applicable to many aspects of human sexuality. Consider, for instance, the emotion of jealousy. Evolutionary psychologists place a strong emphasis on sex differences in this domain. The standard claim is that men are more worried by a partner’s sexual infidelity than emotional infidelity, whereas women are more worried by a partner’s emotional infidelity... the overwhelming trend is that most men and most women are extremely upset by both sexual and emotional infidelity. This suggests that the central EP claim regarding jealousy should be “Human beings evolved to experience jealousy in romantic relationships” rather than “Men and women evolved different patterns of jealousy.” The latter statement is true but should be considered a qualification to the former: a peripheral rather than a central claim. To stress the sex difference alone would be like observing that male elephants are bigger than females while steadfastly neglecting to mention that all adult elephants are large compared to most terrestrial animals. It would almost certainly foster an inaccurate view."
React to this quote
More by Steve Stewart-Williams
See allResonant Thoughts
"In the fall of 1964 an interesting meeting was held one evening in Los Angeles. It was composed of some twenty assorted psychiatrists, psychologists, scientists, et al—and myself. It was a most reward…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Feminist-in and out of science- often condemn masculine bias in the sciences from the vantage point of comm…"
— Helen Longino"One thing I am convinced more and more is true and that is this: the only way to be truly happy is to make …"
— William Carlos Williams"The Bhagavad Gita is not as nice a book as some Americans think…Throughout the Mahabharata … Krishna goads …"
— Wendy Doniger O'Flaherty"Two seemingly incompatible conceptions can each represent an aspect of the truth … They may serve in turn t…"
— Louis de Broglie"And even if what they showed you is true, that doesn’t begin to make it right. The cause might be just, Fel…"
— Alastair Reynolds"The true history of my administration will be written 50 years from now, and you and I will not be around t…"
— George W. Bush