"For instance, if you have by a lie hindered a man who is even now planning a murder, you are legally responsible for all the consequences. But if you have strictly adhered to the truth, public justice can find no fault with you, be the unforeseen consequence what it may. It is possible that whilst you have honestly answered Yes to the murderer’s question, whether his intended victim is in the house, the latter may have gone out unobserved, and so not have come in the way of the murderer, and the deed therefore have not been done; whereas, if you lied and said he was not in the house, and he had really gone out so that the murderer met him as he went, and executed his purpose on him, then you might with justice be accused as the cause of his death. For, if you had spoken the truth as well as you knew it, perhaps the murderer while seeking for his enemy in the house might have been caught by neighbours coming up and the deed been prevented."
React to this quote
More by Immanuel Kant
See allResonant Thoughts
"No live organism can continue for long to exist sanely under conditions of absolute reality; even larks and katydids are supposed, by some, to dream. Hill House, not sane, stood by itself against its …"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"With Bacon, Vico continuously asserts the claims of grammar as true science precisely because it has not yi…"
— Marshall McLuhan"If you desire a man to tell you comfortable lies about your prowess, and so fetter any hope of true excelle…"
— Lois McMaster Bujold"The strangest, most generous, and proudest of all virtues is true courage."
— Michel de Montaigne"When truth and reason cannot be heard, then must presumption rule."
— Barbara Tuchman"Feeling does not succeed in converting consolation into truth, nor does reason succeed in converting truth …"
— Miguel de Unamuno"At the most elemental level, reality evanesces into something called Schröedinger's Wave Function: a mathem…"
— Rudy Rucker