"On the surface it appeared that the Stalinist intervention was to defend the materialism of Marx against the idealism of Hegel. In reality the theoretical threat came from the revolutionary dialectical logic. In political economy the Stalinists seek to defend the classless nature of state-property and planning. The theoretical enemy is the theory of state-capitalism. In philosophy they seek to propagate the fiction of the classless nature of rationalism and materialism. The enemy is the proletariat resisting labor discipline by the bureaucracy. Again and again Zhdanov attacked Alexandrov for "objectivism.” The Stalinists are terrified by the obviously growing conviction that there is in Stalinist Russia an "objective” basis for the "struggle of opposites, the struggle between the old and the new, between the dying and the rising, between the decaying and the developing.” Such an objective basis could only be the class struggle. Hence they must purge Marxism of the Hegelian concept of the objectivity of contradiction."
React to this quote
More by C. L. R. James
See allResonant Thoughts
"In conclusion, a word about your tired expression that there is a difference between theory and praxis. ... Thereby you want to say that praxis should be an unencumbered as possible by theory. Coming …"
"The members of the Vienna Circle are working out a ‘Logical Empiricism’. Following Ernst Mach and Poincaré, but above all Russell and Wittgenstein, all the sciences are treated uniformly. Carnap’s Log…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"To make the happy was not my objective, but to make the say, “Yeah, that’s what would happen” — that was my…"
— Jack Kirby"As the degree of observational accuracy at which general relativity becomes significantly different from Ne…"
— Gerald James Whitrow"Archie's been living off the fat of the land. I'm here to give him his pension plan. When you come to the f…"
— Muhammad Ali"Increasingly... the application of mathematics to the real world involves discrete mathematics... the natur…"
— Richard Hamming"Being out of the closet is a luxury that many gay people can't afford. Maybe you can't understand that, but…"
— Michael Nava"Not to have a national anthem would be logical."
— George Orwell
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Stephen King on philosophy
- Robert A. Heinlein on philosophy
- Ernest Hemingway on philosophy
- Mark Twain on philosophy
- George Bernard Shaw on philosophy
- Anton Chekhov on philosophy
- Virginia Woolf on Philosophy
- Ursula K. Le Guin on philosophy
- Stephen King on life
- Stephen King on time
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change
