"will reply that they are considering the meaning of a "thought," not of a word. A "thought" is not a social phenomenon, like speech, and therefore does not have the two sides, active and passive, which can be distinguished in speech. I should urge, however, that all the reasons which led our authors to avoid introducing images in explaining meaning should have also led them to avoid introducing "thoughts." If a theory of meaning is to be fitted into natural science as they desire, it is necessary to define the meaning of words without introducing anything "mental" in the sense in which what is "mental" is not subject to the laws of physics. Therefore, for the same reasons for which I now hold that the meaning of words should be explained without introducing images – which I argued to be possible in the above-quoted passage – I also hold that meaning in general should be treated without introducing "thoughts," and should be regarded as a property of words considered as physical phenomena. Let us therefore amend their theory. They say: "'I am thinking of A' is the same thing as 'My thought is being caused by A.'" Let us substitute: "'I am speaking of A' is the same thing as 'My speech is being caused by A.'" Can this theory be true?"
React to this quote
More by Bertrand Russell
See allResonant Thoughts
"The hon. Member for Manchester asks, "What is our interest in this war?" and he also asked me to explain the meaning of the expression "the balance of power." ... "Balance of power" means only this—th…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Using the popular macroeconomic models of the time, Lucas and Sargent showed how replacing traditional assu…"
— Olivier Blanchard"What a computer is to me is it's the most remarkable tool that we have ever come up with. It's the equivale…"
— Steve Jobs"I'm not sure I ever 'got it' when it comes to how to live my life in a way that was original and free," ref…"
— Herb Goldberg"I have said to people when they ask me, if this Capitol crumbled to the ground, the one thing that would re…"
— Nancy Pelosi"He thought others were small; that was his greatness."
— Dejan Stojanovic"“I think Vajpayee is a dyed-in-the-wool RSS man."
— Atal Bihari Vajpayee