"Here's my own horror story with academic publishing. I was an intern at an industry research lab, and came up with a relatively simple improvement to a widely used cryptographic primitive. I spent a month or two writing it up as well as I could using academic language and conventions, etc., with the help of a mentor who worked there and who used to be a professor. Submitted to a top crypto conference and weeks later got back a rejection with comments indicating that all of the reviewers completely failed to understand the main idea. The comments were so short that I had no way to tell how to improve the paper and just got the impression that the reviewers weren't interested in the idea and made little effort to try to understand it. My mentor acted totally unsurprised and just said something like, "let's talk about where to submit it next." That's the end of the story because I decide if that's how academia works I wanted to have nothing to do with it when there's, from my perspective, an obviously better way to do things, i.e., writing up the idea informally, posting it to a mailing list and getting immediate useful feedback/discussions from people who actually understand and are interested in the idea."
React to this quote
More by Wei Dai
See allResonant Thoughts
"I have grown accustomed to the disrespect expressed by some of the participants for their colleagues in the other disciplines. "Why, Dan," ask the people in artificial intelligence, "do you waste your…"
"It has long been a fashion amongst you, which you have had the complaisance to adopt at the instigation of a corrupt press, to call every friend of reform, every friend of freedom, a Jacobin, and to a…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"However, such myths developed earlier in the Byzantine periphery. In the heart of the Empire, it was really…"
— Anthony D. Smith"It's perhaps fitting that I write this introduction in jail."
— Abbie Hoffman"“Recent Poetry”, p. 226"
— Randall Jarrell"The more destruction there is everywhere, the more it shows the activity of town authorities."
— Nikolai Gogol"This is a history, in that it intends to describe what happened and suggest why. … I may have fooled around…"
— Neal Stephenson"It shouldn't be hard to imagine just what most of the crew must have thought when they first looked across …"
— Norman Maclean
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Bran Ferren on writing
- Larry Wall on writing
- Linus Torvalds on writing
- Vitruvius on writing
- Erik Naggum on writing
- N. R. Narayana Murthy on knowledge
- N. R. Narayana Murthy on leadership
- N. R. Narayana Murthy on books
- N. R. Narayana Murthy on creativity
- N. R. Narayana Murthy on education
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change

