#writing
"And of course, translation, again is a ‘re’-translation” of others’ works” in which she has “merely added a fashionable Freudian coating… Simple question: if ‘that’ much is wrong in just one story — what about the rest of this book and her other translations?… It might have been better to have used the old translations and to have added her Freudian interpretation to them… In sum: The “translation” simply is UNREALIABLE... In view of all of this, I wonder indeed whether Doniger’s translation would have been accepted in the Harvard Oriental Series rather than in Penguin… And a little less hype would also do: ‘a landmark translation, the first authoritative translation in this century’ ; ‘to offer to more specialized scholars new interpretations of many difficult verses.’ — I doubt it."
React to this quote
More by Wendy Doniger O'Flaherty
See allResonant Thoughts
"A fifth kind of semantic awareness has to do with what might be called the "photographic" effects of language. We live in a universe of constant process. Everything is changing in the physical world a…"
— Neil Postman
Literature1931–2003
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"In mirth that after no repenting draws."
— John Milton"The handwriting of any individual would be found to resemble the characteristic tracings shown by his pulse…"
— June Downey"They have two of the world’s best young players in Cristiano Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney, but the player who m…"
— Paul Scholes"Words of Wisdom An extended range of quotations from the Writings of Emanuel Swedenborg."
— Emanuel_Swedenborg"Sai holds the universe in his hand"
— Sathya Sai Baba"Samples of John Wilmot's bawdy poetry at Pornokrates"
— John Wilmot

