"One cannot speak of "groups" as though society were objectively subdivided... Instead, people draw lines, attribute differences, as a way of ordering social justice—of deciding who may occupy what place, play what role, engage in what activity. Thus, in order to justify the role of chattel that blacks initially played in our society, we may have differentiated that role by describing it in terms of the most obvious distinguishing feature... equating race and role. This equation and thus "group" survived the Civil War and the Thirteenth Amendment... simply by reason of confusion or inertia, but because the role that society allowed remained partially unchanged; thus, the need to justify the role by differentiating it, by seeing not the role but the group—"inferior" blacks capable of nothing better...—persisted."
React to this quote
More by Laurence Tribe
See allResonant Thoughts
"What is to be the nature of the domestic legislation of the future? I cannot help thinking that it will be more directed to what are called social subjects than has hitherto been the case.—How to prom…"
"We remain dedicated to accomplishing greater social justice through a fairer sharing of wealth and opportunity. We will stay the course, because it is right for Fiji."
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"The laws of chivalry required that every knight should pass through two offices: the first was a page; and,…"
— Joseph Strutt"In Ukraine, you don't build a democracy; it already exists. You just defend it."
— Petro Poroshenko"I hit play, the music started, and that's when my nerves got the worst, because it was like, There's no goi…"
— Austin Mahone"He wasn't just a genius, he had the genius's impatience with the whole idea of doing something again. He re…"
— Clive James"I have finished a fairly large painting, the goat; I sometimes spoke to you about my plan. I believe it has…"
— Jan Mankes"The only law that a Christian should listen to and read is the law of God's Commandments. And it is not rig…"
— Jan Hus
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on justice
- Randy Pausch on justice
- Laurence Tribe on justice
- Margaret Sanger on justice
- Karl E. Weick on justice
- George Saintsbury on justice
- Gary Yourofsky on justice
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on life
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on truth
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on knowledge
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change

