"Edmund Gettier convinced most philosophers that the received wisdom of millennia about the concept of knowledge was mistaken: “knowledge” was not simply a matter of having a justified, true belief … A justified true belief isn’t “knowledge” when the justification for the true belief isn’t the cause of why the agent holds the belief. As Philip Kitcher put the point, in explaining the stimulus Gettier provided to the “naturalistic” turn in epistemology: “the epistemic status of a belief state depends on the etiology of the state.” … We can understand, now, the logic of the hermeneutics of suspicion as exploiting precisely this point about the epistemic status of belief: we should be suspicious of the epistemic status of beliefs that have the wrong causal etiology. That’s the lesson of the Gettier counter-examples, and it is the lesson which underwrites the suspicion that Marx, Nietzsche, and Freud recommend by way of providing alternative causal trajectories to explain our beliefs. To be sure, beliefs with the wrong causal etiology might be true; but since they are no longer cases of knowledge, we have no reason to presume that to be the case."
React to this quote
More by Brian Leiter
See allResonant Thoughts
"The historical order is very interesting, but accidental and capricious; if we would to understand the growth of knowledge, we cannot be satisfied with accidents, we must explain how knowledge was gra…"
"These are the duties of the overseer: He should maintain discipline. He should observe the feast days. He should respect the rights of others and steadfastly uphold his own. He should settle all quarr…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"The liberty of the citizen to do as he likes so long as he does not interfere with the liberty of others to…"
— Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr."Barnes dismissed his own past criticism of the World War II unconditional surrender policy as valid but sup…"
— Murray Rothbard"But mathematics Thorby saw no use in, other than the barbaric skill of counting money. But presently he lea…"
— Robert A. Heinlein"What we deplore is not that the gate of western knowledge was thrown open to Indians, but that such knowled…"
— Syama Prasad Mookerjee"The higher we go, the ups and downs at the lower level would gradually fade. If what we do is to be worth w…"
— D. V. Gundappa"It is a difficult thing to grow up knowing that the thing where we can hold on to take root is dead."
— Juan Rulfo
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Friedrich Nietzsche on knowledge
- Baruch Spinoza on knowledge
- Thomas Carlyle on knowledge
- Aristotle on knowledge
- Immanuel Kant on knowledge
- Ludwig Wittgenstein on knowledge
- Michel de Montaigne on knowledge
- Epictetus on knowledge
- Friedrich Nietzsche on life
- Friedrich Nietzsche on truth
- justice & Beauty
- justice & Change
