"This is a common criticism: the idea that the atheist is guilty of a literalist reading of scripture, and that it’s a very naive way of approaching religion, and there’s a far more sophisticated and nuanced view of religion on offer and the atheist is disregarding that. A few problems with this: anyone making that argument is failing to acknowledge just how many people really do approach these texts literally or functionally - whether they’re selective literalists, or literal all the way down the line. There are certain passages in scripture that just cannot be read figuratively. And people really do live by the lights of what is literally laid out in these books. So, the Koran says “hate the infidel” and Muslims hate the infidel because the Koran spells it out ad nauseam. Now, it’s true that you can cherry-pick scripture, and you can look for all the good parts. You can ignore where it says in Leviticus that if a woman is not a virgin on her wedding night you’re supposed to stone her to death on her father’s doorstep. Most religious people ignore those passages, which really can only be read literally, and say that “they were only appropriate for the time” and “they don’t apply now”. And likewise, Muslims try to have the same reading of passages that advocate holy war. They say “well, these were appropriate to those battles that Mohammed was fighting, but now we don’t have to fight those battles”. This is all a good thing, but we should recognize what’s happening here: people are feeling pressure from a host of all-too-human concerns that have nothing, in principle, to do with God: secularism, and human rights, and democracy, and scientific progress. These have made certain passages in scripture untenable. This is coming from outside religion, and religion is now making a great show of its sophistication in grappling with these pressures. This is an example of religion losing the argument with modernity."
React to this quote
More by Sam Harris
See allResonant Thoughts
"I must make a protest against the sort of exaggerations in which the noble Lord has indulged. He has described the railway launching 2,000 or 3,000 ruffians upon some quiet neighbourhood in a manner t…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Nothing, in truth, has such a tendency to weaken not only the powers of invention, but the intellectual pow…"
— Dugald Stewart"It won't be covered in the book. The source code has to be useful for something, after all..."
— Larry Wall"The procrastinator dreads beginning, the workaholic, ending."
— James Richardson"Alas for poor Jadunath Sarkar, who must have turned in his grave if he were buried. For, after reading his …"
— Sita Ram Goel"Yes, secularism does propose a physical and purposeless universe, and many of us accept the notion that our…"
— Jerry Coyne"Ultimately, literature is nothing but carpentry."
— Gabriel García Márquez
