"Let me take the example which is today the greatest sacred cow of them all—Social Security. Was there an overwhelming demand for Social Security in the 1930s when the law was adopted? Far from it. There was no public demand for it, it had to be sold. How was it sold? By the slickest devices of Madison Avenue, by imaginative packaging and deceptive labeling. Social Security was sold as an insurance scheme. It is not an insurance scheme. There is very little relationship to the amount of money any one individual pays and the amount of money he is entitled to receive. Social Security is a combination of a bad tax system with a bad way of distributing welfare… If you look at the tax system, who could defend a wage tax, a tax on wages up to a maximum, a tax on work, a tax which discourages employers from hiring people, and discourages people from going to work; a tax which is borne by the lowest wage group, workers? It is a regressive tax. You could never in a million Sundays… have gotten such a tax passed as a tax."
React to this quote
More by Milton Friedman
See allResonant Thoughts
"We may have pledged to support the freedom of the people so that we ourselves may enjoy the results. We are working for the sake of God and for the sake of the people. We do not need to be known, nor …"
"Manufacture is a word, which, in the vicissitude of language, has come to signify the reverse of its intrinsic meaning, for it now denotes every extensive product of art, which is made by machinery, w…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"The development, strengthening and multiplication of socially minded businessmen is the central problem of …"
— Rakesh Khurana"The single most important stimulus to my thought came by chance when I took a course from Robert Redfield e…"
— William H. McNeill"Power is mostly the illusion of power. The Pentagon demanded we destroy our publications. We kept publishin…"
— Julian Assange"Mitterrand's Legacy" in The Nation"
— François Mitterrand"That no man, or set of men, are entitled to exclusive or separate emoluments or privileges from the communi…"
— George Mason"Increasingly constructive doubt is the sign of advancing civilization. We must put question marks along man…"
— Jerome Frank
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- David Cay Johnston on society
- Norman Angell on society
- Bernard Lietaer on society
- David Cay Johnston on politics
- David Cay Johnston on time
- David Cay Johnston on justice
- David Cay Johnston on life
- David Cay Johnston on knowledge
- David Cay Johnston on art
- David Cay Johnston on philosophy
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change
