"Already in the verdict cited by Ginés de Sepúlveda are mentioned a lot of these criteria which the Western philosophical academy nowadays uses against the supposed “indigenous philosophies”: “culture”, “letters” , “history”, “written laws”. We are dealing with a violent and excluding act of “definition” that excludes a priori the other. When one defines “philosophy” as a product elaborated by individuals and expressed in written texts , using a binary logic and a discursive rationality, thus one excludes per definitionem all philosophical expressions that don’t have an individual author, that aren’t put down in writing, that don’t obey the logical principle of the formal non-contradiction and that apply a non-discursive rationality. Ergo: non philosophia est."
React to this quote
More by Josef Estermann
See allResonant Thoughts
"In the following decades “Kierkegaard remained completely unknown, Schelling’s work was contemptuously buried, and Marx and Feuerbach were interpreted as dogmatic materialists. Then a new impetus came…"
"Let me take the example which is today the greatest sacred cow of them all—Social Security. Was there an overwhelming demand for Social Security in the 1930s when the law was adopted? Far from it. The…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"s Reason's A. Barton Hinkle pointed out, New York’s notorious stop-and-frisk policies, which left-wing mayo…"
— Adam Garfinkle"The ethos of science involves the functionally necessary demand that theories or generalizations be evaluat…"
— Robert K. Merton"My goal is simple. All I want to do is re-connect people with animals. Awaken some emotions and some feelin…"
— Gary Yourofsky"... a lion wants to eat an antelope's body, but the antelope has very different plans for its body. This is…"
— Richard Dawkins"Psychoanalysis, which interprets the human being as a socialized being, and the psychic apparatus as essent…"
— Erich Fromm"According to Saeed Ramadan in his book Ḍawābiṭ al-Maṣlaḥ and Muslehuddin in The Philosophy of Islamic Law, …"
— Said Ramadan
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Baruch Spinoza on philosophy
- Friedrich Nietzsche on philosophy
- Thomas Carlyle on philosophy
- Aristotle on philosophy
- Immanuel Kant on philosophy
- Ludwig Wittgenstein on philosophy
- Michel de Montaigne on philosophy
- Epictetus on philosophy
- Baruch Spinoza on knowledge
- Baruch Spinoza on mind
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change