"Characteristic of the Semitic religions are features such as a historically attested teacher or prophet, a sacred book, a geographically identifiable location for its beginnings, an ecclesiastical infrastructure and the conversion of large numbers of people to the religion-all characteristics which are largely irrelevant to the various manifestations of Hinduism until recent times. Thus instead of emphasizing the fact that the religious experience of Indian civilization and of religious sects which are bunched together under the label of ‘Hindu’ are distinctively different from that of the Semitic, attempts are being made to find parallels with the Semitic religions as if these parallels are necessary to the future of Hinduism. “The teacher or prophet is replaced by the avatâra of Vishnu, Rama; the sacred book is the Râmâyana; the geographical identity or the beginnings of the cult and the historicity of Rama are being sought in the insistence that the precise birthplace of Rama in Ayodhya was marked by a temple, which was destroyed by Babur and replaced by the Babri Masjid; an ecclesiastical infrastructure is implied by inducting into the movement the support of Mahants and the Shankaracharyas or what the Vishwa Hindu Parishad calls a Dharma Sansad; the support of large numbers of people, far surpassing the figures of earlier followers of Rama-bhakti, was organized through the worship of bricks destined for the building of a temple on the location of the mosque."
React to this quote
More by Romila Thapar
See allResonant Thoughts
"When we have weighed everything, and when our relations in life permit us to choose any given position, we may take that one which guarantees us the greatest dignity, which is based on ideas of whose …"
"No religion is absolutely perfect. Yet not only do we fight for religion, but also are we often willing to sacrifice our lives for it. And what we hopelessly fail to do is to live it. A true religion …"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Judy lived in my hotel. She was just seventeen, and what she was doing in Paris was supposedly chaperoning …"
— Elaine Dundy"Concerning the nature of the cyclical times when the great teachers either appear personally in the world o…"
— Gottfried de Purucker"I strive that in public dissection the students do as much as possible."
— Andreas Vesalius"We have, all of us, with a few unlucky exceptions, for which special schools are required, hands, eyes, and…"
— George Long (scholar)"The idea of schooling free men in anything would have revolted Athenians. Forced training was for slaves. A…"
— John Taylor Gatto"A little unsure of himself in her presence, he always addressed her in questions, a habit common to parents…"
— André Maurois
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on education
- Randy Pausch on education
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on life
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on truth
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on knowledge
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on freedom
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on mind
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on philosophy
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on love
- Nisargadatta Maharaj on time
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change

