"Gould's argument on reification purports to get at the philosophical foundation of the field. He claims that general intelligence, defined as the factor common to different cognitive abilities, is merely a mathematical abstraction; hence if we consider it a measurable attribute we are reifying it, falsely converting an abstraction into an “entity” or a “thing”—variously referred to as “a hard, quantifiable thing,” “a quantifiable fundamental particle,” “a thing in the most direct, material sense.” Here he has dug himself a deep hole.… Indeed, this whole argument is fantastic. The scientist does not measure “material things”: He measures properties , sometimes of a single “thing” , and sometimes of an organized collection of things, such as a machine, a biological organ, or an organism. In a particularly complex collection, the brain, some properties have been traced to narrowly-localized regions ."
React to this quote
More by Stephen Jay Gould
See allResonant Thoughts
"And here I cannot help mentioning a very ridiculous show of a learned pig, which of late days attracted much of the public notice, and at the polite end of the town. This pig, which indeed was a large…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"I strongly believe that fundamental science cannot be driven by instructional, industrial and government or…"
— C. V. Raman"To the dumb question "Why me?" the cosmos barely bothers to return the reply: Why not?"
— Christopher Hitchens"If we compare one country of the civilized world with another, or one part of England with another, or one …"
— Alfred Marshall"Between the finite and the infinite The missing link of Love has left a void. Supply the link, and earth wi…"
— Ella Wheeler Wilcox"As the old confusion of tongues was laudable, when men who were of one language in wickedness and impiety, …"
— Gregory of Nazianzus"Robbed of a foundation of political philosophy on which it had based itself, economics is in great danger o…"
— Eric Roll
Related Thinkers
Related Topics
Deep Dives
- Albert Einstein on philosophy
- Stephen Jay Gould on philosophy
- Carl Sagan on philosophy
- Charles Darwin on philosophy
- Michael Parenti on philosophy
- Galileo Galilei on philosophy
- Giordano Bruno on philosophy
- J. R. Partington on philosophy
- Albert Einstein on life
- Albert Einstein on science
- knowledge & Beauty
- knowledge & Change
