"When I have asked thinking men what reason they had to believe that every fact in the universe is precisely determined by law, the first answer has usually been that the proposition is a "presupposition " or postulate of scientific reasoning. Well, if that is the best that can be said for it, the belief is doomed. Suppose it be " postulated " : that does not make it true, nor so much as afford the slightest rational motive for yielding it any credence. It is as if a man should come to borrow money, and when asked for his security, should reply he "postulated " the loan. To "postulate" a proposition is no more than to hope it is true. There are, indeed, practical emergencies in which we act upon assumptions of certain propositions as true, because if they are not so, it can make no difference how we act. But all such propositions I take to be hypotheses of individual facts. For it is manifest that no universal principle can in its universality be compromised in a special case or can be requisite for the validity of any ordinary inference."
React to this quote
More by Charles Sanders Peirce
See allResonant Thoughts
"Fundamentally, our chief problem may be summed up as the effort to make men as nearly as they can be made, both free and equal; the freedom and equality necessarily resting on a basis of justice and b…"
"The revolutionary and critical thinker is in a certain way always outside of his society while of course he is at the same time also in it. That he is in it is obvious, but why is he outside it? First…"
Explore Further
Related Quotes
"Although I like to be thought of as a tough rugby-playing Welsh miner's son, able to take on the world, the…"
— Richard Burton"Mullah Faizullah: It wasn't your fault,Mariam. Don't think this way. This will destroy you, my girl. It was…"
— Khaled Hosseini"To call out for the hand of the enemy is a rather extreme measure, yet a better one, I think, than to remai…"
— Michel de Montaigne"The Hindu mind works in such a way that continuity of worship is more important than physical fact. When th…"
— Michel Danino"Perfection of rhythm, balanced perfection of rhythm. Everything in Nature is expressed by rhythmic waves of…"
— Walter Russell"It was during the war, and they thought Kraft was too Teutonic, and they said I would be compared to Kraft …"
— Virginia Christine
